London, GB | Formerly of New York, Buenos Aires, Fife, and the Western Cape. | Saoránach d’Éirinn.

Bring Back the Broadsheet!

THE DECLINE OF Scotland’s nation newspaper is marked and lamentable. Once exhibiting a certain grace and dignity, the Scotsman was the most respected of Caledonian dailies. It was the only to have bureaus overseas, and it presided as king of the newspaper realm from stately offices on the heights of North Bridge. All of that, of course, is all gone. It’s all about cost-cutting and driving up circulation instead of maintaining the role as Scotland’s newspaper of record.

The conversion from broadsheet to tabloid was supposed to be one of pure convenience. All those people on the bus need a smaller paper to read! But it has seriously affected the very essence of the newspaper. What was once weighty and serious is now cursory and flippant. The Scotsman‘s remaining redeeming feature is the presence of Mr. Alexander McCall Smith and his 44 Scotland Street serial.

Broad sheet, broad mind.

I guess I should stick to reading fictional newspapers.

Link: The Daily Excess

Published at 8:26 pm on Wednesday 31 October 2007. Categories: Newspapers Scotland.
Comments

Can you count the things the liberals would object to in the image of the old Scotsman?

1) Harold Macmillan
2) A judge’s wig
3) The Pope
4) 12-year sentence for spy traitor

Robert Harrington 1 Nov 2007 8:29 am

I never was fully comfortable with reading newspapers except on Sunday, when I took the liberty of spreading it on the coffee table in the family room. Otherwise, on buses or park benches, I found it a bit cumbersome to read — It certainly requires a bit of skill to flip it and fold it. The worst part is when a newspaper has sections (which tend to fall out) or when a story is scattered over several non-sequential and disjointed pages.

Thus, for most things, I’ve preferred journals and magazines, for both news/business and pleasure reading.

But this is not to say that I will accept tabloid journalism. (I spent too many years as editor of a few publications for that.) I hate how ‘newspapers’ today feel as if becoming more ‘relaxed’ and ‘user-friendly’ also translates to relaxing the standards of journalistic integrity and prioritization of news reports. Let alone their blatant disregard for the economic use of ink! I call to mind several New York papers (with which I’m sure you’re well aquainted) as prime examples of what should not be done. These, and the new Scotsman shown above, exemplify how sensationalism and novelty have trumped good sense and tradition.

And thus, cumbersomeness aside, I much prefer the old broadsheet.

Alessandro 1 Nov 2007 9:54 am

Note the headline at the bottom of Page One of the fine old broadsheet:

“Pope Paul likely to be more cautious.”

That story must have been missed by his liturgists.

MCNS 1 Nov 2007 5:14 pm

A rather unfortunate choice of photo for your ‘broad mind’ comment!

Stuart Paterson 1 Nov 2007 5:17 pm

I foolishly didn’t think anyone would recognise him, Stuart!

Andrew Cusack 1 Nov 2007 9:54 pm

Come back and save the Scotsman Mr. C. Its not too late, yet. I could see you working in the old offices on North Bridge. I spent the night there once and very nice it was, but it would be splendid to see it used for the paper again.

Adrian 2 Nov 2007 3:04 pm

When the more recent Irish Independent are put on the Irish Newspaper Archive website the broadsheet size will be put up as main paper while the tabloid will be put up as its Metro supplemeant. They are no plans for may be 15- 20 or even 25 years the broadsheet size of Irish Independent will remain in circlelation for years to come since the tabloid version was launched in January 2004. They wont be a Sunday Tabloid for the Irish Independents Sunday Newspaper The Sunday Independent will remain published in broadsheet only for the next number of years but there will a new look Sunday Independent in all broadsheet with not much change as ever.

Martin Walsh 1 Oct 2010 3:22 pm

They are now all more newspaper on the Irish Newspaper Archives website now as The Irish Independent withdrew its Broadsheet last weekend and make the full to change to Tabloid some sections and the Sunday Independent are to remain in broadsheet size.

Martin Walsh 28 Dec 2012 2:48 pm
Leave a comment

NAME (required)

EMAIL (required)

WEBSITE (not required)

COMMENT

Home | About | Contact | Paginated Index | Twitter | Facebook | RSS/Atom Feed
andrewcusack.com | © Andrew Cusack 2004-present (Unless otherwise stated)