Comments on: Our Cardinal Strikes Again

By: Bonifacius

Bonifacius — Fri, 02 Jul 2010 13:23:00 +0000

This is all very fascinating, especially the question of the Scottish Primacy. It reminds me of the battle between the Archbishops of Canterbury and York over the Primacy of England.

By: Maddie

Maddie — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 01:28:04 +0000

Deo Gratias! Another priest to carry on the Traditions of the Faith!

By: Nick

Nick — Wed, 09 Jun 2010 03:20:15 +0000

The Archbishop of St. Andrews (and, after 1878, St. Andrews and Edinburgh) has been primate of Scotland since 1472, but this primacy was established against the protests of the bishops of Glasgow and from 1492, the archbishop of Glasgow was exempt from the jurisdiction of St. Andrews, answerable directly to the papacy as “specialis filia Romanae sedis.” This title had been used in the 13th cent. to protect Scottish sees against the primatial claims of the archbishops of York.

I *think* (though I’m not sure) that the Glaswegian exemption was revived at some point after the revival of the Catholic hierarchy in Scotland and is still in force.

The origins of the division really have their origins in the fact that early Christian “Scotland” (like “England”) was actually a Balkans of petty kingdoms, with “Scots” (i.e. Irish) dominant in the west and Picts and Anglians dominant in the East. I’m not sure which see is older, but my guess is that it’s Glasgow. I know St. Mungo/Kentigern is said to have come from Fife, but, on the whole Scotland was evangelised from the west. Glasgow fell within the semi-Romanised kingdom of Strathclyde, and the remains of the Antonine wall and various other Roman remains are only a few hours walk from the centre of the city.

By: Louise

Louise — Tue, 08 Jun 2010 14:31:15 +0000

FrPF, Brad did not imply that Glasgow wasn’t old enough to be taken seriously. They are your words not his.

FrJO, The Catholic Encyclopedia says that St. Andrews and Edinburgh is a primatial see. The late Archbishop MacDonald (of happy memory) used to get very annoyed (along with all Scots Catholics) when the press referred to the Archbishop of Westminter as the “leader of Britain’s Catholics” (something they still do sometimes)and would write to them pointing out that there was no leader of Britain’s Catholics and that Westinster’s Archbishop was the leader of English Catholics. When he was asked who was the leader of Scotland’s Catholics he always replied firmly, and proudly, “I AM!”

By: Fr JO

Fr JO — Tue, 08 Jun 2010 07:26:43 +0000

Brad, what is this then: “St. Andrew’s and Edinburgh has always been the prmatial see in Scotland”? What evidence do you give that this is true? For as a priest of said Archdiocese, I know of no one who has ever claimed this title or even thought to claim that title other than on here!

By: Fr PF

Fr PF — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 22:18:49 +0000

Thank you, Fr JO.
Brad, with regard to the notion that the Glasgow diocese is not old enough to be taken seriously, Glasgow simply became a metropolitan see in 1492; the diocese can name its bishops back to the eleventh century and owes its origins to Saint Mungo or Kentigern, first Bishop of Glasgow and founder of the city in the sixth century.
I came across an interesting (for me as a Passionist) quotation from a letter of Lord Bute to the Cardinal Prefect of Propaganda in June 1877:
‘Glasgow is one of the most ancient bishoprics of Scotland, founded by St. Kentigern, whose Relics still remain in the beautiful cathedral and whose office has for some years been authorized by the Holy See for the Passionists of this city’ (quoted in Vincent McClelland’s article ‘A Hierarchy for Scotland, 1868-1878′, The Catholic Historical Review (Catholic University of America Press), Vol. 56, No. 3 (Oct., 1970), p.493).

By: Brad

Brad — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 22:02:09 +0000

I am not trying to pass off any false information and so I spelt the name wrong, i made a mistake. We can’t all be perfect like you!

By: Fr JO

Fr JO — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 17:13:47 +0000

Come on Brad! If you are going to try and pass of false information about the Archdiocese of St Andrews and Edinburgh – at least get the name right!

As Fr Paul Francis states, KP O’Brien is “head” of the Scottish Church due to the position he holds as President of the Bishop’s Conference, just as TJ Winning was before that and GJ Gray before that.

By: Andrew Cusack

Andrew Cusack — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 13:50:20 +0000

Fascinating stuff! My thanks to the various commenters for their contributions.

I think we can probably attribute a customary or traditional primacy to St Andrews & Edinburgh, but it seems clear from the evidence presented that this has no official force.

Given the relative importance of Glasgow to the Scottish Church, that lack of official force seems quite reasonable to me.

By: Fr PF

Fr PF — Mon, 07 Jun 2010 13:05:24 +0000

Campbell, am I quite sure? Not of anything unless it’s in the Creed or the Catechism, but here are my thoughts on this:
When the Hierarchy was restored by Pope Leo XIII, St A&E was set up as a metropolitan see with almost all the Scottish dioceses as suffragans. The exception was Glasgow which was to be governed by an Archbishop with no suffragans but directly subject to the Holy See (Leo XIII, Ex Supremo Apostolatus, 1878). This was possibly done out of respect for Archbishop Eyre, the first Archbishop of Glasgow in the restored Hierarchy, who remained Apostolic Delegate for Scotland until his death. Leo XIII says it was because Glasgow is an ancient, great and noble city which had been made an archiepiscopal see by Pope Innocent VIII (in 1492). In 1947, with the creation of the dioceses of Motherwell and Paisley, Glasgow became a metropolitan see. Cardinal O’Brien is the President of the Scottish Catholic Bishops Conference; his predecessor was the late Cardinal Winning, who was Archbishop of Glasgow.
As for traditional usage, I personally have never heard or seen the expression ‘Primate of Scotland’ used of a an Archbishop of St A&E until now (but then, being from Glasgow, how would I?), although the present Episcopal Bishop of St Andrew’s is the ‘Primus of Scotland’ in the Anglican Communion.